- 01Which questions reveal whether an SEO agency is a good fit?
- 02How will the agency develop its strategy and priorities?
- 03Questions about evidence and expectations
- 04How will the agency deliver the work?
- 05Questions about costs, access and communication
- 06FAQs
- 07Questions to ask a new SEO agency before you sign
Which questions reveal whether an SEO agency is a good fit?
The most useful questions ask an agency to explain its decisions, rather than simply describe its services. Find out why it recommends particular work, how that work supports your commercial goals and what happens after you sign. The answers should help you judge whether its approach fits your business.
An agency does not need to deliver a complete strategy during an introductory call. It should explain its discovery process, what information it needs and where its initial recommendations remain provisional.
Use the questions below during a proposal meeting. Ask each shortlisted agency the same core questions so you can compare the substance of its answers. Our guide to choosing the right SEO agency covers the wider selection process.
For purchases involving a complex buying group, our B2B agency-selection guide provides useful background as you prepare for those conversations.
How will the agency develop its strategy and priorities?
Ask how the agency will learn about your business and decide where to focus its efforts. Its answers should explain how your goals inform its initial priorities and choice of pages to target. This gives you a basis for judging the reasoning behind its proposed work.
1. What do you need to learn about our business first?
Look for questions about profitable services, customer types, sales cycles, geographical coverage and delivery capacity. Search demand only becomes commercially useful when it connects with something your business can sell and fulfil.
For example, an agency should know if your priority is generating fewer, higher-value enquiries rather than increasing every type of website visit.
2. What would you investigate and prioritise in the first 90 days?
Ask for an outline of the initial audit, measurement checks and implementation priorities. A useful answer explains the sequence and dependencies, including what your team must provide.
Be cautious if every prospect receives the same plan without investigation. A site with indexing problems needs a different starting point from one attracting visitors to poorly converting service pages.
3. How will you choose keywords and pages to target?
The agency should consider search intent, commercial relevance, competition and your existing content. Ask how it will avoid creating several pages that answer essentially the same question.
Request one example: which service or topic would it investigate first, and why? The reasoning matters more than a large spreadsheet of keywords without an implementation plan.
Questions about evidence and expectations
Evidence and expectations are easier to assess when an agency explains both what it can support and what remains uncertain. Ask how it will measure progress against your business goals, and look for a clear account of its contribution to any result it presents as relevant.
4. Can you explain a relevant result and your contribution?
Ask about the starting position, timescale, work delivered and outcome. Clarify whether reported growth involved branded searches, paid activity, seasonality or a website migration.
Challenge broad superiority claims too. CAP’s guidance on “leading” claims explains why objective advertising claims need supporting evidence. “Leading agency” is not a substitute for a relevant example you can assess.
5. How will you measure success for our business?
Ask which measures will influence decisions: suitable enquiries, sales, organic conversions, relevant visibility and landing-page performance. Establish how lead quality will be fed back to the agency.
Request a sample report showing what happened, what was completed and what comes next. Separate branded from non-branded performance where useful, so growing awareness does not obscure weak acquisition activity.
6. What can you commit to, and what remains uncertain?
An agency can commit to agreed work, communication and reporting. Forecasts should explain their assumptions and dependencies.
Bing’s Webmaster Guidelines state that SEO does not guarantee rankings or traffic, and GEO does not guarantee AI citations. Ask how progress will be reviewed if results fall short of expectations.
How will the agency deliver the work?
Ask who will carry out the work and how the agency approaches its main delivery methods. You need to understand who is responsible for implementation, how content and backlinks fit into the work, and how the agency approaches AI search. Its answers should also make the proposed scope clear.
7. Who will do the work and implement the changes?
Establish who manages your account, who performs specialist work and whether subcontractors are involved. Ask who actually changes the website.
Some retainers cover recommendations while implementation requires your developer. Others include hands-on changes. Neither arrangement is inherently wrong, but unclear responsibilities can leave useful recommendations sitting in a document for months.
8. How do you create content and use AI?
Ask how the agency gathers your expertise, checks facts and handles editorial approval. If AI accelerates production, clarify who reviews the output and how original examples are added.
You should understand what additional delivery the workflow makes possible. Article volume alone tells you little about whether the content answers customer questions or supports your services.
9. How will you earn backlinks and approach AI search?
Request examples of proposed link sources and the editorial reason another website would mention your business. Ask how paid placements and unsuitable opportunities are handled.
For AEO and GEO, ask which platforms matter to your customers, what changes are proposed and how mentions or citations will be checked. “AI optimisation” should come with a defined scope and reporting method.
Questions about costs, access and communication
Clarify the practical terms of the relationship before agreeing to work with an agency. Ask what your fee covers, who controls accounts and completed work, and how you will communicate. These answers help you understand the arrangement as well as how it will be reviewed.
10. What does the fee include, and what costs extra?
Clarify audits, content, technical implementation, outreach, reporting and meetings. Ask about software charges, developer fees, VAT where applicable and approval for additional spending.
Compare proposals against the same requirements. Our guide to UK SEO agency costs explains the scope differences to examine alongside the monthly price.
11. Who controls our accounts and completed work?
Confirm that your business retains appropriate control of its website, analytics and search tools. Agree content ownership, access permissions and handover arrangements in writing.
Use named access with suitable permissions rather than casually sharing owner credentials. The NCSC’s identity and access guidance recommends limiting access according to what users need to do.
12. How will we communicate and review the agreement?
Agree a main contact, update schedule and route for urgent issues. Ask how changes are approved, documented and checked after implementation.
Clarify the minimum term, notice period and handover process. Our article on what to expect from an organic search agency explains how those responsibilities translate into an ongoing working relationship.
Frequently asked questions
Should an agency provide a free audit before you sign?+
An agency does not need to provide a detailed free audit before you sign. A preliminary review can help explain its proposal, but a detailed audit requires time, data and specialist analysis. Ask what the review covers and what remains unverified, then judge the usefulness of its observations rather than the number of issues in an automated report.
Can you ask to speak to an existing client?+
Yes, you can ask whether an existing client with comparable needs is willing to discuss the relationship. Respect confidentiality and accept that an introduction may require permission. Ask about communication, implementation and how the agency responds when something goes wrong, as well as the results achieved.
What should you send before the first meeting?+
Before the first meeting, share your website, priority services, target customers, current concerns and a realistic budget range. Mention any previous SEO work and a planned redesign. Detailed account access can follow once its purpose is clear, so use the first conversation to establish what information the agency needs and why.
What if the agency cannot answer everything immediately?+
It is reasonable for an agency not to answer everything immediately when a question requires research or input from a specialist. A useful response identifies the uncertainty, explains how it will be investigated and sets a follow-up date. Be more concerned by repeated evasion or confident recommendations made without enough information to support them.
Questions to ask a new SEO agency before you sign
The right questions help you understand how an agency makes decisions and whether its approach supports your business goals. Ask what it needs to learn, how it will prioritise work and measure progress, and what evidence supports its recommendations. Clarify who will deliver and implement the work, how content, backlinks and AI search fit into the approach, and what remains uncertain. Before signing, check the fee, account ownership, communication arrangements and agreement review. Take the same core questions to each shortlisted agency and compare the substance of the answers. Use any uncertainties as prompts for follow-up, rather than expecting a complete strategy at the first meeting.
